Recommit, Pivot or Release
RPR (pronounced R-Par): the verdict that closes Hansei, at the horizon or after an Abort.
Hansei ends with a verdict that changes the next move. The verdict is used in Hansei to inform the next Ishi, and the Spiral turns again only after one of these is recorded.
- RecommitThe Ishi remains valid and boundaries stay intact.
- PivotA change of strategy, keeping the vision. The new strategy is a new Ishi.
- ReleaseThe intent is dropped because the evidence no longer supports the bet.
A Pivot or an Adjust
Pivot is often used for any change of course. In the Ishi Spiral the 2 words are kept apart. An Adjust is a change of tactic that keeps the same strategy. A Pivot, in the sense Eric Ries gave the word in The Lean Startup, is a change of strategy that keeps the same vision.
An Adjust happens in flight, as one of the 3 answers of AHA (pronounced A-Hey). A Pivot changes the strategy the Ishi was set on, so it waits for that Ishi to end, at the horizon or with an Abort. A Pivot made in mid flight leaves an invalid Ishi, a commitment whose strategy no longer matches what was set at the start.
After a Recommit or a Pivot, one change is recorded: a boundary, a trigger, the practice design or a constraint. The rest is held steady long enough to see signal. If no single change is declared, Hansei did not occur.
At the last horizon, which of the 3 was recorded, and what one thing changed?
Read the original
The Structure of The Ishi Spiral
Ishi on Substack. The whole Spiral in one issue, with the verdict as the close of the Reflect phase.
Weekly Kaizen 5: Hansei, the Reflect Phase
Ishi on Substack. The 5 audit themes of the Reflect phase, ending the week with a verdict.