Persist or stop

Persistence fails in 2 directions: continuing too long, and stopping too early.

Persist is where a decision meets time. Novelty fades, progress slows, and the work keeps asking for effort after the reasons for it have stopped feeling fresh. Persist (Gaman) is restrained endurance governed by judgement. It holds effort steady while the original intent remains valid.

  • Continuing too longUngoverned persistence is continuing after the decision that authorised effort has expired, broken or become invalid. It is dangerous because it often looks admirable from the outside. Barry Staw described the pattern in 1976. In his experiment the participants who had personally made a decision and then watched it fail committed the most money to it afterwards.
  • Stopping too earlyPremature quitting interprets discomfort as threat. Difficulty is misread as misalignment, and the work is abandoned before practice has had time to take effect.

Persistence and judgement are separate skills. Persistence answers whether you can continue. Judgement controls whether continuing still makes sense. Fatigue degrades judgement first, so the thresholds are set in the Decide phase, while judgement is clear and identity has not yet attached itself to the effort.

In flight the mechanism is AHA (pronounced A-Hey). Adjust keeps the commitment and changes the tactic, Hold keeps the load when the signal is discomfort, and Abort ends the commitment before continuing costs more than it is worth.

Persist also needs a horizon. Endurance without an end date erodes judgement, because continuation that was conditional starts to be treated as absolute. At the horizon the question goes to Reflect (Hansei), which ends in Recommit, Pivot or Release.

Weekly Ishi 15 describes a 1,000-day running streak as the phase working as designed. The end date and the rules were set before day 1. When illness came the pace was adjusted and the commitment held, and the streak stopped on the day the decision said it would.

What is being persisted with now, and when was it last decided that it still deserves the effort?

Read the original

Weekly Ishi 15: Persistence over the Long Arc

Ishi on Substack. Endurance held in proportion, with one account of each failure and the streak that ended on its set day.

Three paperback copies of Ishi: The Discipline of Determined Intent by Gareth A Holebrook, foreword by L. David Marquet

IshiThe Discipline of Determined Intent