The governance gap
Effort applied competently, without governance.
Failure is rarely caused by an absence of effort or competence. Work continues, metrics hold and confidence grows. Then the decision underneath has stopped being valid, and the signals that said so went unread while the system was still functioning.
Motivation increases energy and leaves direction ungoverned. A motivated person inside an ungoverned system becomes a faster expression of whatever the system is already doing wrong.
Where the gap opens
- In the decisionThe commitment was adopted from culture or peers, started before it had settled, or stacked from reasonable yeses without a governing no.
- In the practiceWhen correction threatens competence, intensity replaces precision. Volume climbs, sessions lengthen and fatigue becomes proof of commitment.
- In the persistenceEndurance fails on either side. Premature quitting reads discomfort as damage. Ungoverned persistence continues after the intent that authorised the effort has expired.
- In the reflectionReview comes after the cost is in the system, or without distance, and the decision is judged by how it turned out.
The 4 openings behave as one system. The phases of the Ishi Spiral are coupled, so a patch to one phase moves the failure to the next. A weak decision is forged faithfully by practice, and it stays hidden until persistence exposes it.
One question finds the gap. Take the effort defended most strongly today, and ask whether the decision underneath it is still current and fits in one honest sentence.
Read the original
Ishi on Substack. The phrase introduced, with the 4 phases, AHA (pronounced A-Hey) and the Ishi Card.
Weekly Ishi 3: The Problem I am Trying to Solve
Ishi on Substack. The gap separated into 4 openings, and why the 4 behave as one system.